Big discounts are not marketing. They are a loan you take from your own margin, and the whole market pays it back.
I watch the same cycle on Instagram every season. One seller drops 30%. The next one drops 40%. A month later, nobody in the niche makes money, and buyers refuse to pay the old price anywhere.
This post shows the math most sellers never do, why discounts train your buyers to wait, the one case where a discount makes sense, and what to do instead.
What does a 20% discount really cost you?
A discount is taken from your margin, not from your price. That is the part sellers forget.
Take a product you sell at 3,000 DA. It costs you 2,200 DA to buy, pack and send. Your margin is 800 DA.
Now run 20% off. The price drops by 600 DA. Your costs did not move. Your margin is now 200 DA.
| Discount | New price | Margin per order | Orders needed to earn the same 800 DA |
|---|---|---|---|
| None | 3,000 DA | 800 DA | 1 |
| 10% | 2,700 DA | 500 DA | 1.6 |
| 20% | 2,400 DA | 200 DA | 4 |
| 30% | 2,100 DA | minus 100 DA | You lose money on every order |
At 20% off, you need four orders to earn what one order used to give you. Four times the packing, four times the calls, four times the parcels that can come back.
This is not just a small seller problem. McKinsey's analysis of large companies found that a 1% price cut lowers operating profit by about 8%, and that a 5% cut needs 18.7% more volume just to break even (Marn, Roegner and Zawada, 2003). Their margins are thicker than yours. Yours break faster.
Why do discounts train buyers to wait? 🧠
Every discount teaches your buyer something: the full price is optional.
Researchers followed eight years of real purchase data and found that consumers became more sensitive to price and promotions as promotions increased (Mela, Gupta and Lehmann, 1997). The more often a brand discounts, the more its buyers wait for the next one.
You see it in your DMs. "Is there a promo coming?" "I'll buy when you do a sale." That buyer is not being difficult. You taught them.
How does one discount break the whole market?
A price war is not one decision. It is a chain.
- You cut 20% to get a good week.
- Your competitor sees fewer orders and cuts 25%.
- You answer with 30%, because now your old price looks expensive.
- The buyer learns that this product "really" costs 2,100 DA.
At the end, nobody wins the week. Everybody lost the margin. And the new seller who wants to sell at a fair price looks like a thief.
The Algerian reality 🇩🇿
Most online sales here are cash on delivery. That changes the math in a way that makes discounts more dangerous, not less.
A discount brings impulse orders. Impulse orders are the ones most likely to be refused at the door. And when a parcel comes back, you often pay delivery anyway. On a 200 DA margin, one returned parcel can wipe out the profit of several good orders.
Instagram markets are also small and visible. Every seller in your niche sees your price within hours. A discount here is not a private decision. It is a signal to the whole market.
When does a discount make sense?
There is one good case: you are new, and nobody knows you yet.
A launch discount buys attention you cannot get any other way. Your first buyers, your first reviews, your first photos from real clients. That is worth paying for. But it needs three rules:
- A clear end date. "Launch week only, until Friday." Then it really ends.
- A reason. "To celebrate the opening." A discount with a reason does not lower your normal price in the buyer's head.
- A limit. The first 50 orders, or one product only. Not the whole catalogue.
After launch, the discount does not come back every week. If it does, it is not a launch anymore. It is your new price.
What to do instead of a discount 🛠️
Compete on value, not on price. Give more instead of taking less.
- Packaging. A clean box and a thank you card make 3,000 DA feel like a fair price.
- Speed. Fast delivery and a quick confirmation call are worth more than 10% to most buyers.
- A small gift. Something that costs you 100 DA and feels like 500 DA.
- Free delivery above a basket amount. It raises the order value instead of lowering the price.
- Bundles. Two products together at a better price raise your margin per order instead of cutting it.
- Reward returning buyers. A loyal client deserves a thank you, privately. The whole market does not need to see it.
Before you run any promotion, do the table above with your own numbers. If the margin after discount does not cover a returned parcel, do not run it.
TL;DR 🧾
Discount = a loan from your margin that the whole market repays.
A 20% discount can cut your profit per order by 75%, and regular promotions teach buyers to wait. Use a discount once, to launch, with an end date and a reason. After that, compete on packaging, speed and service, not on price.